| 1980 | Bill Utzinger | Casper | 1995 | Robert L. Prill | Sheridan |
| 1981 | Roy Gaswint | Cheyenne | Donald Nolte | Lander | |
| Charles Haines | Cheyenne | 1998 | Louise Judd | Gillette | |
| 1982 | Charles Mankin | Gillette | Cecil Miller | Wheatland | |
| Adam Helzer | Sheridan | 1999 | John Von Kennel | Cheyenne | |
| Leonard Helzer |
Laramie | Richard Catrerral | Sheridan | ||
| 1983 | Floyd Hale | Iron Mtn. | 2000 | Terry Barnhart | Buffalo |
| Ralph Macy | Cheyenne | John Quealy | Casper | ||
| 1984 | Clair Boyer | Casper | 2001 | Lee Beekley | Casper |
| Troy Jones | Laramie | Van LeM aster | Cheyenne | ||
| 1985 | Dave Farrar | Casper | Jim Oler | Casper | |
| 1986 | Lorris Carr | Casper | 2002 | Ed Christian | Jackson |
| George Wilkens | Casper | 2003 | Fred Bruegger | Lusk | |
| 1987 | Harry Sodeman | Casper | 2004 | David Allan | Cheyenne |
| Henry Rost | Casper | Don Orester | Rock Springs | ||
| Henry Stanko | Casper | 2005 | Gary Olson | Torrington | |
| 1988 | J.B. Eccles | Casper | Sandra Aitken | Shoshoni | |
| Peg Keeline | Gillette | 2007 | Bruce Reed | Douglas | |
| 0. Fred Finley | Dubois | Walt Sturman | Lusk | ||
| 1989 | Dick Mankin | Gillette | John Campbell | Buffalo | |
| 1990 | Phil Kiner | Cheyenne | 2008 | Joy Trim | Evansville |
| Morris Senstock | Casper | Nick Hann | Midwest | ||
| E.E. Oldfield | Cheyenne | 2009 | Tanie Ball Heitz | Laramie | |
| 1991 | Fred Norwood | Sheridan | Darrell Jones | Evanston | |
| Lowell Judd | Gillette | Jack Fredrickson | Cody | ||
| Mary Henderson | Casper | 2010 | No selections made | ||
| Jim Butler | Gillette | 2011 | Goodie Norwood | Sheridan | |
| 1992 | Fred BallCasper | ||||
| Les Hildebrand | Gillette | ||||
| 1993 | Glenda Stark | Casper | |||
| 1994 | Tony Black | Gillette | |||
